Supermarket Beauty Lookalikes Might Save You Hundreds. However, Do Affordable Skincare Products Really Work?

A consumer holding skincare products Rachael Parnell
Rachael comments with a few lookalikes she "cannot distinguish the distinction".

Upon hearing one shopper heard Aldi was selling a fresh beauty line that appeared similar to items from premium company Augustinus Bader, she was "super excited".

Rachael dashed to her local store to purchase the supermarket face cream for under £9 for 50ml - a tiny percentage of the £240 cost of the Augustinus Bader 50ml cream.

The sleek blue tube and gold cap of each creams look strikingly comparable. And though Rachael has not used the luxury cream, she states she's satisfied by the product so far.

Rachael has been buying beauty alternatives from high street stores and grocery stores for some time, and she's not alone.

Over a quarter of UK consumers say they've tried a skincare or makeup dupe. This jumps to 44 percent among millennials and Gen Z, based on a February survey.

Dupes are skincare products that imitate established brands and offer cost-effective alternatives to premium items. They typically have similar branding and containers, but in some cases the components can vary substantially.

Side-by-side of high-end and affordable face creams Victoria Woollaston
Luxury vs budget: Augustinus Bader's 50ml face cream is priced at £240, while the supermarket's recent Lacura face cream is £8.49.

'Expensive Is Not Necessarily Better'

Skincare professionals contend some substitutes to premium brands are decent standard and aid make skincare less expensive.

"In my opinion costlier is always better," comments skin specialist Sharon Belmo. "Not every low-budget skincare brand is inferior - and not every high-end skincare product is the top."

"A number of [dupes] are absolutely excellent," adds a skincare commentator, who runs a program about famous people.

Numerous of the products based on luxury brands "run out so fast, it's just insane," he remarks.

Skincare expert Scott McGlynn Scott McGlynn
Skincare expert Scott McGlynn says a few budget items he has used are "great".

Aesthetic and dermatology doctor a doctor thinks alternatives are suitable to use for "basic skincare" like moisturisers and cleansers.

"Dupes will be effective," he says. "They will perform the basics to a acceptable standard."

Ketaki Bhate, advises you can save money when searching for single-ingredient products like HA, Vitamin B3 and squalane.

"If you're purchasing a simple product then you're likely going to be alright in opting for a budget alternative or a product which is very affordable because there's not much that can cause issues," she adds.

'Do Not Be Influenced by the Container'

But the experts also suggest shoppers check details and say that higher-priced items are at times worthy of the premium price.

Regarding high-end beauty products, you're not just covering the name and promotion - at times the elevated price tag also stems from the formula and their grade, the potency of the key component, the technology utilized to create the item, and studies into the products' effectiveness, the expert explains.

Facialist another professional says it's worth considering how certain dupes can be offered so at a low cost.

Sometimes, she says they might contain less effective components that don't have as significant advantages for the complexion, or the components might not be as well sourced.

"The major doubt is 'Why is it so cheap?'" she says.

Commentator Scott admits sometimes he's purchased skincare items that look similar to a well-known label but the product itself has "no resemblance to the original".

"Don't be fooled by the outer appearance," he warned.

Skincare products on a shelf SimpleImages/Getty Images
An expert recommends sticking to established brands for products with components like retinol or ascorbic acid.

Regarding advanced items or those with components that can aggravate the skin if they're not made properly, such as retinols or vitamin C serums, the specialist advises selecting more specialised brands.

The expert explains these will likely have been subjected to costly studies to assess how efficacious they are.

Beauty items are required to be tested before they can be marketed in the UK, notes consultant dermatologist Emma Wedgeworth.

If the label states about the efficacy of the item, it must have evidence to support it, "but the brand doesn't always have to conduct the trials" and can alternatively cite testing completed by different companies, she says.

Examine the Label of the Container

Are there any ingredients that could signal a item is low-quality?

Components on the list of the tube are ordered by concentration. "Ingredients to avoid that you want to look out for… is your petroleum-derived oil, your sodium lauryl sulfate, parfum, benzel peroxide" being {high up

Tara Carpenter DDS
Tara Carpenter DDS

Wildlife biologist and conservationist specializing in sloth research, with over a decade of field experience in Central and South American rainforests.